SALT LAKE CITY, Utah (Good Things Utah) – Whether you melt into summer or are ready to head back to school, there’s no better way to do than with a delicious sandwich made with Cache Valley Cheese! This is one of our favorite lunch menu recipes from Cache Valley Creamery – the zesty Pizza Grilled Cheese Sandwich. Easy to make. Tasty to eat!

The star of the recipe.. Cache Valley Cheese slices! Don’t forget about the convenience of Cache Valley Creamery’s cheese slices. They’re perfect for layering in sandwiches or melting on burgers for that ultimate cheesy indulgence.

Elevate your summer grilling with Cache Valley Creamery’s cheese. Experience the irresistible melt and savor the real, wholesome flavor.


  • 1 tbsp. Cache Valley® Butter, softened
  • 2 slices light Italian bread or 1 deli round flat bun
  • 1 tbsp. marinara sauce
  • Pinch dried oregano
  • 6 slices 25% less fat pepperoni
  • 2 slices Cache Valley® Provolone Cheese


  • HEAT a medium non-stick skillet over medium heat.
  • SPREAD ½ tbsp. of butter on 1 side of each bread slice or on the outside of the flat bun and place butter-side down on a cutting board or plate.   
  • PLACE 1 slice of cheese onto 1 slice of bread. Top with the marinara sauce, pepperoni and oregano. Finish with the remaining slice of cheese and the 2nd piece of bread, butter-side up.   
  • PLACE the sandwich into the pan, butter-side down.  
  • COVER with a lid and cook for 2 to 3 minutes or until bottom slice of bread is golden. Carefully flip the sandwich and continue cooking until the second slice of bread is golden and the cheese has melted.   
  • REMOVE from heat; slice and enjoy.

Click here to print a copy of the featured recipe.

Visit for more information about all of Cache Valley’s delicious products. Cache Valley Creamery’s cheese is inspired by the Valley, reflecting the goodness and values of the community.

And let’s talk about string cheese! Cache Valley Creamery’s string cheese is a must-have for summer snacking. Its convenient and portable format makes it ideal for on-the-go moments and picnic adventures

Sponsored by Cache Valley Creamery.