Utah native wins lawsuit to have her sex change operation paid for


Story Comments Share
Updated: 10/08/2012 9:33 am | Published: 10/04/2012 10:24 pm
Reported by: Kimberly Nelson
SALT LAKE CITY (ABC 4 News) – A Utah native wins battle with her insurance company to have her sex-change operation paid for.

34-year-old Ida Hammer was born a man, but says she’s always been a woman.

“A lot of people say a woman trapped in a man's body, but like I said, I’m a woman and this is my body so it's a woman's body,” explained Hammer. “It's just that there's thing I want to change about it."

Hammer was raised LDS in Brigham City and for years didn’t know what it meant to be transgendered.

“Struggling with it and not knowing it’s possible and just feeling a lot of shame,” said Hammer. “It was a process to work through that.”

With the help of her friends and doctors she did work through it and about four years ago, after moved to New York, she decided it was time to make her final transition into womanhood and have a sex change operation.

She applied for pre-authorization for her male-to-female sex surgery in July 2011. MVP Health Care denied her claim on the grounds that it was cosmetic and therefore not covered under her policy.

Hammer said, "My request was denied and I appealed it twice and it was denied twice. Finally with the help of the Transgendered Legal Defense and Education Fund, and a threat of a lawsuit, MVP Health Care changed its stance and agreed with Hammer’s doctors that the sex operation was “medically necessary.”

Executive Director of Transgender Legal Defense and Education Fund, Michael Silverman said, "The American Medical Association, and every credible medical organization out there, has said the same thing - transitional related health care is medically necessary for transgendered people."

Hammer hopes this decision forces other insurance companies to change their policy and encourages other transgendered people to complete their transition.

"You don't have to hide or pretend if it’s something you've been struggling with throughout your life,” said Hammer.

Hammer expects to have her surgery next year.
Story Comments Share
5 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of ABC4

surfthis - 10/8/2012 5:55 PM
0 Votes
Boy can't change his DNA.... Can change the package, but it's still a fella... Constitutes fraud.

darrin - 10/8/2012 12:18 PM
0 Votes
don't understand why people get assisitance for such frivilous operations and most of the time at the hardworking taxpayers expense yet when good honest hard working people need gov't and/state aid they get laughed at

rararara - 10/6/2012 8:05 AM
2 Votes
Plenty of people see themselves differently than they appear outwardly; its not a disease, its called life. Fat girls feel thin inside, ugly ones feel pretty. Short guys might feel like they were really meant to be tall, and stupid people somehow surmise they might have been meant to be smart. The real disease is thinking you're such an important special snowflake that you dont have to suck it up and either deal with it or pay your own way to your wondrous transformation.

Marissicle - 10/6/2012 4:17 AM
1 Vote
In response to the other comment, actually DNA proves nothing, there are a variety of occurances in which there are XX males, XY females, and XXY or XYY males or females, or intersex babies. Some intersex people produce both XX and XY cells. Most intersex babies have surgeries forced upon them at birth to decide their sex. Quite a large percentage of these babies later on transition to the opposite sex to match their internal gender. Also in cases of bone marrow transplants DNA has been known to change. What actually drove me to reply to this article was the statement "born a man." There is no such thing as being "born a man" any more than one could be "born a woman." You are born a BABY and neither sex nor gender is necessarily on a binary scale, but rather a large scale with many points.

surfthis - 10/6/2012 12:11 AM
0 Votes
DNA is and always will be male... Change the package and it's still and always will be a fella.
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.