Utah lawmaker proposes to raise food tax


Story Comments Share
Updated: 11/16/2012 5:45 pm | Published: 11/15/2012 7:12 pm
Reported by: Kim Johnson

SALT LAKE CITY (ABC 4 News) - A Utah lawmaker says it's time to shell out more cash for groceries. 

 

Sen. John Valentine is proposing to double the state's food tax from 1.75 percent to 4.75 percent. The senator says the tax was cut five years ago and since then the state is hurting in the sales tax department.

 

The idea of paying more for food has people like Alisa Haws, mom of two growing boys with growing appetites question their budgets. “It would make me look for more bargains.”

 

Crystal Couch said it would make her re0think where she buys groceries.  “That would definitely change our priorities of where we would shop at,” she said. “Luckily my husband is military so we can go to the base so that would definitely make us drive a little bit farther to make us not pay taxes.”  

 

Under the proposal there is relief for low-income families. An individual or family making less than $35,000 a year would get an $80 tax credit to offset the cost of sales tax on groceries. A family making $60,000 or less would get $40 per person. Families who qualify for the federal Earned Income Credit would get a state refundable credit of five percent.

 

But even with safeguards for the needy, not everyone is sold.

 

“At least those people that are really desperate won’t be hurting, but for the rest of us if you make just so much and you have just enough assets and you don't get help from the government that could hurt a lot of people,” said Douglas MacDonald, a shopper.

 

Story Comments Share
7 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of ABC4

Teerevor - 11/16/2012 12:29 PM
0 Votes
I thought Republicans were against raising taxes?

ullh82w8 - 11/16/2012 10:54 AM
0 Votes
The reason citizens are paying such a high tax rate is to give breaks to Corporations to locate in UT. I think it is a decent plan, that is why UT has lower unemployment rate. But there has to be a median. Look at fuel prices, look at food prices, if they didn't raise the price, they cut the amount of item. ENOUGH!

Dennis - 11/16/2012 2:58 AM
1 Vote
Please explain to us common folks how a proposed food sales tax increase from 1.75% to 4.75% equates to a "doubl[ing]" when even a person educated in public schools can figure out that 4.75 divided by 1.75 is nearly triple (2.7 times) that amount! But I suppose that's only to be expected when a Republican, BYU-educated, Mormon politician/lawyer like Valentine is entrusted to do the math and promote his own taxing agenda. And don't give us that pious, pitiful crap about "the state is hurting in the sales tax department" when Jon Huntsman's final parting shot was to impose a $1 per pack Mormon "sin" tax on cigarettes when he left to be the U. S. Ambassador to China. What are these religious bureaucrats doing with all that windfall revenue, to say nothing of the multi-millions the state rakes in from the sale of alcohol and tourism? What about your OWN poor, "Brother Valentine," who depend on Social Security for their existence while struggling to pay ten percent of their annual gross income to their beloved church so their leaders can live in luxury and opulence, gathering once a week to compare clothing? In what need is the Lord that He should want their money, pray tell? And why do lawyers like Valentine persist in fulfilling the prophecy of Alma 10:27? Because they neither read, nor do they comprehend, their own scriptures, that's why! And how is it that states like Montana impose ZERO sales tax on food? Got that? ZERO! Yet Utah (the alter ego of the LDS Church) receives royalties on oil, gas and mining in amounts that can only be wondered at, but are never mentioned publicly. So like I always say, based on long personal experience: YEP, URINE UTAH for sure, and getting hosed regularly every day -- just as in the days when that old hypocrite Brigham Young owned the largest brewery between the Mississippi and the West Coast. But I guess I shouldn't say that in polite company because you could always look it up for yourself if you wished, plus tax.

Badgerboy - 11/15/2012 10:29 PM
1 Vote
Senator John Valentine apparently doesn't see that our nation's economy is in the dumper with pending federal tax increases on the way. People are out of work, losing their homes, and living on fixed incomes. This clown pushes for an increase in taxes on food too? Senator John Valentine needs to voted out of office the next time he's up for re-election. I say to his constituents remember this idea of his.

CA Native - 11/15/2012 9:08 PM
0 Votes
so they propose giving back in the form of a rebate so much money per person. How is that going to bring more money into State coffers? Just put a limit on how any kids you can get thousands for on your taxes - limit to 3 each family. Tax Pampers and use that money for schools, just 5 cents per sm. pack of Pampers, larger package, 10 or 15 cents. And yes, pepsi, coke, ice cream - come on, a couple cents on soda. These are not necessities and it wouldn't hurt poor or elderly unless they choose to purchase soda and ice cream. Pampers tax would help the educational system. This makes more sense than taxing all food items which do hurt poor and elderly.

ullh82w8 - 11/15/2012 8:43 PM
1 Vote
Just remember that common sense is raising ANY TAX during a recession onlyhas a stifling effect on recovery.

gunner - 11/15/2012 7:57 PM
1 Vote
that sounds about right, raise the food taxes and those of us that are on fixed income or low income can go hungry, or try to get food stamps so we can eat.
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.