Religion thrust into forefront of governor's race


Story Comments Share
Updated: 8/27/2010 5:27 pm | Published: 8/27/2010 3:06 pm
Gary Herbert and Peter Corroon
Gary Herbert and Peter Corroon
By BROCK VERGAKIS
Associated Press Writer

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) - Religion in this heavily Mormon state is being thrust to the forefront of the debate over who should be Utah's next governor.

The running mate of the Catholic Democratic nominee accused the state's Mormon Republican governor on Friday of introducing a religious wedge into the race.

At issue is the long-held practice of allowing children in Utah schools to leave campus each day for religious education. About 60 percent of Utah's residents belong to The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and Mormon seminary schools are generally found next to each of the state's high schools. To attend seminary, students must give up one of their electives. In most states, Mormon students typically attend seminary before or after school.

On Thursday, Herbert suggested that Corroon's plan for requiring students to take four years of math and science to graduate could force students to abandon their seminary release time.

"Electives you're going to have to give up in Utah under his proposal are gonna be some arts and probably seminary time," Herbert said. "I don't know that everybody in Utah's going to think that's a good idea to give up art and seminary release time in order to have this more rigorous curriculum."

Corroon's plan doesn't require students to give up art or seminary release time. Utah currently requires students to earn 24 credits to graduate, including six electives.

Under Corroon's plan, only four electives would be required.

Students would still be free to choose what electives those are and most school districts have room in their schedules for additional electives. Many school districts have a schedule that allows students to graduate with 32 credits.

Corroon's running mate, GOP Rep. Sheryl Allen, said there's plenty of room for seminary and art under their proposal and that Herbert is unnecessarily scaring people.

"It's unfortunate that a religious wedge has been interjected by Gary Herbert, because the discussion is about the future of our children and preparing them for the 21st Century," said Allen, a Mormon.

Herbert's comment about seminary was the second time this week he made subtle references to religion and education. On Monday, Herbert's campaign released a statement saying Corroon was nearing hypocrisy for saying he supports public education when his children go to private school. Corroon's three children attend a Catholic school in their neighborhood. Allen said she expressed bewilderment that Herbert brought up Corroon's decision to send his children there.

"The issue is preparing our students for the 21st century. It's not about Peter Corroon's children, it's not about Gary Herbert's children," she said.

Herbert campaign spokesman Don Olsen disputed Allen's charges. "He never said that seminary was going to be eliminated," Olsen said. "He was not attempting in any way to inject or to push a religious wedge into the race."

While Allen said there's room for seminary in the school schedule, she also said she and Corroon are open to discussing the possibility of moving it to before or after school. Olsen also said Herbert is open to that possibility if it is something families would prefer.

"If parents think that's the best thing, terrific. That's up to them," he said. "I'm sure that the governor would not be opposed in any way to discussion about whether early morning seminary is right."

Corroon and Herbert are facing off in a special election this November to fill out the remainder of former Gov. Jon Huntsman's term. Huntsman resigned in August to become U.S. ambassador to China, putting Herbert into the state's top job.

(Copyright 2010 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)

Story Comments Share
8 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of ABC4

Charlie8 - 10/2/2010 6:38 PM
Requiring more core credits reduces the ability for students to specialize in the classes that interest them. Specialization is more important in education than more cookie cutter classes that kids are going to glaze over. Caroon's plan is terrible.

copytech - 8/29/2010 6:39 AM
Wiseguy it's not about religion it's about govermentbut you non-mormon just want to put religion into it just like back in 2008 you people didn't vote for the good the a canidate has done in the past but his religion that's why Romney didn't get the republican vote he was the better of the two for the republicans. The votes might of been close between the left and right but then again people bring in Religion , just like now people don't like what Obaman is doing so they say he is Mosilem (sp) I don't spell good , that doesn't mean I'm wrong it just means that I didn't do good in English Class. Back to the subject if you non-mormons can't find anything creditble to find wrong with somebody you bring in Religion. Thank You Very Much

wiseguy - 8/28/2010 9:50 PM
Copytech...I vote and I'm conservative...and I'm on the rolls and choose my name. If your LDS you know what I mean. But who is complaining fact is fact! You may believe in your truths but you can't force them on the the world. You hatred just makes you a target and supports getting rid of religions zealots. You should know that in your attitude and telling Ca native to go home you are just providing another fact to support his truth. We will pray for your understanding tomorrow. God Bless.

copytech - 8/28/2010 5:14 PM
Hay Wise Guy if you think that I am not Possesive I think that if you don't Like something in the state you live in then VOTE for what you want changed , You don't have to always have to bring religion in it I just don't like people compainting and don't do anything about it like VOTING instead of complainting if you didn't like BUSH then you Voted Oboma in as president if you don't like what he is doing then vote someone NEW then same with Governor if you don't like who is in there then vote him/she out of Office and stop compliating I just hope you believe in freedom of religion and let people alone, I guess it come from all the people out there in the world that wants to get readof them MORMONS.

wiseguy - 8/28/2010 9:16 AM
Ca Native is correct. Where else in the world do new schools and seminaries get built next door to each other. The reason for the issue coming up is to remind everyone who is a member and who is not. The reply by copytech shows how possessive and aggressive Mormons can be in protecting themselves. Their in-bread fear of being different automatically puts them on the defensive. They don't realize how offensive this is to many. Copytech's comments are very much like the radical Moslem's view that only they have "TRUTH" thus all others are infidels and not welcome. (No I won't tell anyone which ward I'm in because the TRUTH stated by CA Native is the FACT. Fact is fact and does not involve believed TRUTHS.)

copytech - 8/28/2010 6:03 AM
Ca Native If you don't like Utah then go back to California. If you don't like the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints then leave remember this State was settled by Mormons Because theywas ran out of the United States by People like you that don't like the Church because it tell the TRUTH about folks like you if thier teaching don't go with what you your believwe I thought this country had freedon of Religion as long if it goes along with your thinking !!!!!!!

CA Native - 8/28/2010 5:29 AM
only in Utah...there is absolutely NO separation of church and state here. My daughter was teased and ridiculed when she didn't take seminary - we are not LDS so why at the time I registered her for school back in the early 80's did the school insist? It's not as bad now however I still am 'let known' at my government place of employment in So. Utah that being non-LDS is still 'beneath' everyone else. Meetings bring jabs and constant church talk. A child's education is for the three R's - if parents are insisting in seminary, it should be before or after school and not take away from their education and needed electives which will strengthen their lives in the real world when they have to make that money for their families. And why is it there is always some 'private property' available at all middle and senior high schools for these seminary buildings? How can it be possible just enough is available every time a school is built? What are the chances of that happening 100% of the time? Separation of the LDS church and the State of Utah can't exist as long as we have people running this state who can't make a decision without walking to church headquarters, and we all know that happens.

TCM1982 - 8/27/2010 11:12 PM
Herbert shouldn't have brought that up. Separation of church and state doesn't exist here, but it should. I think kids should learn more curriculum they will use in the working world. They will always have time at church to learn what they learn in seminary.
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.