Remark stirs controversy on LDS women's rights and roles


Story Comments Share
Updated: 1/23 5:36 pm | Published: 1/23 3:54 pm
Reported by: Kim Johnson
PROVO, Utah (ABC 4 News) - A comment by LDS’ general young women's president has stirred the pot.

During the January 15th Devotional Address, Elaine Dalton said, "you will understand your roles and your responsibilities and thus will see no need to lobby for rights."

It's unclear what Dalton meant by the comment, but speculation is brewing on the website "Feminist Mormon Housewives".

Jessica writes, "how sad to tell women they should never lobby for rights."
JG writes, "I guess having a uterus disqualifies you from lobbying."
Rune writes "you know what I would absolutely love? If we actually got lessons about how to be like Christ rather than how to be like genders."

Some question if recent campaigns from feminist Mormon women to obtain similar rights as men... sparked Dalton's comment. One campaign had criticized not being able to offer prayers at conference and another protested for the right to wear pants to church.

ABC 4 asked students at BYU Wednesday what they thought of Dalton’s comments and the criticism.

“For me I’m totally not your stereotypical girl, but I don't agree with wearing pants to church and the feminist and modern feminist movements,” said Sarah Flake, a BYU student. “I totally agree with her that you don't have to lobby for rights that are actually rights.”

Another BYU student, Carly Duckworth, said, “I understand my role which sister Dalton was talking about. I understand that is what is expected of me and I don't feel there needs to be any rebellion in that sense.”

ABC 4 reached out to the church and Dalton for a comment, but we were not given one.

To watch the entire address, click here.
Story Comments Share
10 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of ABC4

Tech Writer - 1/29/2013 9:53 AM
1 Vote
For those of you who are members, how can you sustain our general authorities as prophets, seers and revelators; then protest Christ's church or how it is governed? All it shows is you don't feel these men and women are actually inspired by God and filled with the Holy Ghost. We do have women leaders, women do give prayer at conference, when have they not? I cannot let people tear apart Christ's church.

Jeff C - 1/24/2013 8:38 AM
1 Vote
The first viewpoint I read in this article was one "opposing" Pres. Dalton's remark! Also, Jessie's comment was opposing something that Pres. Dalton did not advocate - she did not say to never campaign for rights, just that you wouldn't see the need. It is sad that some wish to make "an offender for a word" someone who wants to help all women. Women are as free as men in the kingdom of God, some are just blinded by their pride.

salubrious14 - 1/23/2013 11:53 PM
0 Votes
Struggling to distinguish which rights are actually rights.

chris t - 1/23/2013 11:05 PM
0 Votes
I bet a whole ten minutes was spent researching this!

smalldog - 1/23/2013 9:36 PM
0 Votes
This looks like either sloppy, or biased reporting. You cannot accurately report a "controversy" without getting quotes from the opposing side - showcasing only women who find no fault with Pres. Dalton is not balanced and informed journalism. There are multiple Provo based groups (Young Mormon Feminists and Provo Feminists) that may be found through social media, and there are unaffiliated individuals who would probably be willing to comment. You may contact me if you need opposing viewpoints, or I can get you in contact with others who may be able to provide insight as to why there *are* women who find Pres. Dalton's remarks disturbing and frustrating. Disappointing job, ABC4.

smalldog - 1/23/2013 9:30 PM
0 Votes
For a title stating controversy, you only managed to report one side of the issue. Why didn't you find someone who did *not* like Pres. Dalton's quote and ask them what about it seemed offensive? Frankly that's just sloppy reporting. Apart from Feminist Mormon Housewives, there are other Provo centered groups (Young Mormon Feminists and Provo Feminists on Facebook, as well as several unaffiliated individuals who would be willing to explain why some find her remarks so disappointing. If you undertake to report on a controversy, make sure you explain why the matter is controversial, don't just report one side.

Curtis Penfold - 1/23/2013 8:23 PM
1 Vote
Next time you're covering Mormon feminism at BYU, you should contact Young Mormon Feminists. We meet every Monday for Feminist Home Evening.

Anonymous - 1/23/2013 6:35 PM
1 Vote
What poor reporting! Why not ask those who are making a controversy of it why the quote is distasteful? Instead you ask college students who didn't witness anything? Try again.

sam3915 - 1/23/2013 6:24 PM
0 Votes
Thanks for this news story and showing once again ABC4's commitment to promoting the official Mormon Church dogma and agenda in your "reporting". Way to help shame those skeptical Mormon women into just giving in to the brainwashed, useful-idiot 'Stepford Wives' roles dictated for them by their evil, wealth and power worshiping, misogynist, otherwise bigoted, scapegoating, Nazi pseudo-Christian, all-male, Mormon Church leaders.

AZ Jan - 1/23/2013 5:06 PM
0 Votes
Sad
ABC 4 Poll
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.