Dog owner shocked after mix-up kills pet


Story Comments Share
Updated: 9/17/2012 6:03 pm | Published: 9/17/2012 3:54 pm
Written by: Jay Reynolds
Reported by: Kim Fischer
LOGAN, Utah (ABC 4 News) - After a man nursed an injured dog back to health, a neighbor accidentally takes the dog to the humane society.

What happens next leaves the owner angry and stunned.

Hans Peterson likes playing with his two dogs. but he really got attached to an injured stray he named Whitey.

“He was emaciated he couldn't even walk he had a wound on his face that we later deduced it was a gunshot,” said Peterson.

After surgery and months of tender loving care, the bond between them both grew.

“You could feel a crest of fat on the nap of his neck he would run, he would play,” said Peterson. “He would follow me everywhere. He was my buddy.”

And according to Hans, Whitey had recovered from his injuries.

“He was healthy, he was robust. Everyone enjoyed him,” said Peterson.

So, he was crushed to hear Whitey had been euthanized.

“This was wrong that my dog died. Very wrong,” said Peterson.

A neighbor saw Whitey wandering near home and she took him into the Humane Society. Where, within hours Whitey was dead.

“This is very difficult. I haven’t slept at night over this since,” said Peterson.

“There are some cases where an animal control officer sees that the animal is in pain and makes the decision that it would be best for the animal to be put down,” said Barbara Smith the Cache Humane Society.

Its animal control’s decision to put down a sick dog but the humane society backed that decision in Whitey’s case.

“Two of our staff members who were there have provided statements to the animal control officer and they concur with his decision,” said Smith.

Yet, Hans doesn't agree. He says a veterinarian gave Whitey a clean bill of health just days before he was killed.

“This was pure idiocy. I believe there was protocols skipped,” said Peterson.

We contacted the Cache County Sheriff's Office, who’s in charge of animal control.

They did not call us back to give a statement nor do an on camera interview about Whitey's case.

Story Comments Share
7 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of ABC4

stanman65 - 9/21/2012 12:54 PM
0 Votes
It matters not that the dog was not micro chipped or licensed. The dog had obviously been cared for and was not in such a physical condition that he had to be put down right then. Sick or injured dogs get picked up for a variety of reasons and there should ALWAYS be a waiting period to allow an owner to claim the animal, absent critical medical conditions. Very poor job. I would be royally devastated if my dog, who is lame, got picked up and put down all in the span of a few hours. Just appalling!!! Talk to a lawyer sir, or contact rescue groups. If the rules need to be changed, perhaps you can be part of the effort to make sure this does not happen to another dog (and dog owner) again.

asmart91 - 9/18/2012 9:18 AM
0 Votes
Mcgyver22 I think you need to check your facts first. I have been to this animal shelter numerous times and I KNOW that none of these people are bad. They have all been there a long time and NONE of them are there for they pay of the job(because I can tell you know its not that much), they are there for their compassion of animals. If that dog had been there for "months" then the neighbor had to have known. This dog was NOT microchiped or properly registered.By the vets standards it was probably on a better path but if you see a dog that you have no history on and the condition looks really bad then can they really be to blame?

mcgyver22 - 9/17/2012 11:40 PM
0 Votes
I think there are good cops and bad cops, I think there are good people who work in shelters and bad ones. The ones that worked in THIS shelter need to be fired, fined, and make restitution to this man for the loss of his dog. And the neighbor?!! Don't even get me started on the neighbor! I found a little dog friday night coming back from the dog park here in St. George and I've listed her on craigslist, Facebooked her like crazy, took her to the vet to see if she's chipped and taught her how to sit. She's pooped in my house twice (I think she's still trying to figure out my schedule and I've learned that she LOVES to chase the laser light. Then I drove the neighborhood where I found her and asked around, knocked doors. I did CALL the shelter and tell them I had found a dog, described her and left my number but there was NO way I was going to turn her over to them. I'll foster her and then the rescue I work with will find her a good home in time. I think her owners dumped her truthfully, but that certainly shouldn't be a death sentence for her. Animals NEED us to be their voice and they will love us back 10 times over. I laughed so hard tonight from her playing. There was just too much that wasn't right in this story and I Hope this man gets JUSTICE for his furry friend.

Anonymous - 9/17/2012 11:06 PM
0 Votes
This is horrible! What a tragedy that the neighbor didn't bother asking around before taking this dog to the shelter. My little guy ran out after a wind storm blew part of the fence down and a lady visiting from Texas was kind enough to pick him up and find out where he lived and no, he didn't have his collar on, that's beside the point. This so called "Humane" society should be checked into! Bogus!! This poor man!

Diana - 9/17/2012 7:16 PM
1 Vote
This is HEARTBREAKING!!! I was wondering the same about the collar and a Tag but this Dog isn't some wild rat out of the Toilet! It's a Golden Retriever. Really? You don't lose time putting down an animal without waiting if someone comes forward???? If the Neighbor pays that much attention and can't lose time to go out of his way to take this pup to the pound, he obviously must've seen that his Neighbor had been nursing a Dog like him! He couldn't have asked around??? Sounds like a rather personal issue here. That Neighbor needs to be euthanized!!!! This story just breaks my Heart! and so much Humanity for the Humane Society! Freak my house would be a zoo if it was for saving a Pet!

buoycrazy - 9/17/2012 6:21 PM
0 Votes
I would like to ask the owner WHY HIS DOG DID NOT HAVE A COLLAR WITH TAGS OR A MICROCHIP???? Or was the Humane Society so irresponsible that they ignored tags and did not call the owner before euthanizing him. This story is a tragedy!

mcfs69 - 9/17/2012 5:59 PM
1 Vote
"Humane" Society seems to be a misnomer.
ABC 4 Poll
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.