Weather Alert: High Wind Warning expires at 10:00 PM on 5/26, issued at 4:19 AM Aneth, UT | Bluff, UT | Bonanza, UT | Cisco, UT

Shurtleff fears crime may rise if Utah passes Arizona style immigration law


Story Comments Share
Updated: 7/03/2010 2:18 pm | Published: 7/02/2010 3:33 pm
Reported by: Chris Vanocur
(ABC 4 News)
(ABC 4 News)
SALT LAKE (ABC 4 News) - Utah's attorney general is warning that if an Arizona style immigration law is passed in Utah
then crime may go up here.

Mark Shurtleff says some of his best informants are illegal immigrants, ones who may stop talking if a new law is passed.

We were interviewing the attorney general about his new plan for a guest worker program in Utah.

But, right in the middle of the interview, he let something slip.

It's about a possible unintended consequence of passing a tougher immigration law here.

Shurtleff has a special strike force called "Secure."

It focuses solely on illegal immigrants who commit serious crimes in the state.

But he caught ABC 4 off guard when he asked and then answered this question.

Mark Shurtleff: "Guess who the best confidential informants are? They're other illegal aliens."

The attorney general says other then being illegal immigrants, these informants are law abiding citizens who want to help.

He also says the informants provide valuable tips about crimes involving drugs, kidnapping, ID theft and gang activity.

But he adds,

"If we pass an Arizona style law, all my investigators who are working with these confidential informants, trying to get the bad guys who hurt us all,
they won't talk to us anymore."

The attorney general fears an Arizona law in Utah will force his informants underground.

He worries that if a tough law passes here, one targeting all illegal immigrants, then his informants will be afraid to talk to any officers,
even ones they've helped in the past.

"The perception is going to be, if you pass an Arizona style law, that people can no longer talk to cops if you're here illegally
and they won't give us information to go after the worst of the worst."

Shurtleff says he's talked to the likely sponsor of Utah's new immigration bill about this potential problem.

While the General claims was assured an exception would be created to protect his informants,
Shurtleff also hints that crime could go up if they become too afraid to talk.


Story Comments Share
12 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of ABC4

filiusme - 2/14/2011 1:48 PM
0 Votes
This is very stupid, our own a AG hires illegal aliens paid with tax payers money? He should be investigated. I'm glad he didn't run for the Senate, I was going to vote for him. In the last year he has showed his true colores. He is a BIG disappointment.

Bob Rooney - 7/4/2010 2:23 PM
0 Votes
Illegals means MORE police, MORE sheriffs MORE border control, and more Crime. Push your state rep to make a change. Google this: numbersusa. Once you are registered, go to the "action buffet" to send FREE faxes now. Forward this to everyone you know.

NetScanr - 7/4/2010 1:52 AM
1 Vote
IDEAS TO HELP RESOLVE OUR NATION'S EMPLOYMENT WOES: Have the U.S. Government perform an IMMEDIATE AUDIT OF ALL U.S. employers! This will require THOUSANDS in man-power! Hire each employee (Legality verified) AND ENGLISH SPEAKING ONLY of this new group at $20/hr. This fair wage will earn each worker $41,600/year in income, MUCH higher than MOST Utah residents working in call-centers! FINE EMPLOYERS $50,000 FOR EACH AND EVERY ILLEGAL EMPLOYEE. Implement a scale of escalating fines for +10, +20, +30, ILLEGALS etc. Add a BONUS-PACK fine of 150% for companies hiring Mom & Dad ILLEGALS. This system will pay for itself! Each ILLEGAL fine = 1 year's pay for the AMERICAN auditors, with the difference paying for overhead and transport of the located illegal(s) back to their home-country! (Some baggage and fuel fees may apply) This is a sound and fiscally viable solution! Employ Americans at a FAIR wage, and have them help PURGE our country of ILLEGALS, with the American's wage paid-for by the companies fined for their offenses! It won't take long to clean things up! ALL COMPANIES MUST IMMEDIATELY REMOVE their phone system's greetings stating IN SPANISH: "PRESS 'x' IF YOU REFUSE TO LEARN ENGLISH."! YOU'RE NOT IN MEXICO ANYMORE BABY!!! President Obama MUST repeal ALL aspects in the FAIR VOTING ACT that requires ballots and voting materials be printed in SPANISH as well as ENGLISH. WE ARE THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, NOT THE UNTIED ESTATES OF MEXICO!!! When you move here LEGALLY, LEARN OUR LANGUAGE OR GET THE HELL OUT!!! As a U.S. Air Force Retiree, I won't tolerate MEXICANS taking over! All countries in the EU REQUIRE each immigrant pass a written and verbal test before 2 years. If you pass 2 years and still don't qualify?; Back over the fence you go! Very fair, and Very JUST! MOVE HERE, ADAPT TO OUR LANGUAGE AND SOCIETY. NO MORE OF THIS MEXICAN MOVE HERE AND FORCE AMERICANS TO ADAPT TO YOU CRAP! IF YOU WANT TO LIVE HERE LEGALLY, Y

Delaware Bob - 7/3/2010 7:08 PM
2 Votes
I'm from Delaware, and I'm just so proud! We have 68,000 illegal aliens here in our small State and can you believe that the illegal aliens sent so much money out of Delaware that they built up a whole town and then some in Guatemala. OH, hell, Let's give them all AMNESTY! Then we will no longer have to call them illegal aliens, and they will all work to build up America instead of every other Country. Wouldn't they? This will put and end to any more illegal aliens entering this Country. Or will it? Maybe three years from now we will have another 5 million illegal aliens and it will start all over AGAIN!...and soon our Country will be gone. Americans are having less children, while the illegal aliens are having 300,000 children a year, and the best part about this is, they are all paid for by the American Taxpayer, that's you and me. Are you happy now? Do you feel the pride? Maybe it's time for ZERO TOLERENCE with these illegal aliens. Maybe it's time for them get out of this Country and back in their own Country where they belong. When we get rid of the illegal aliens, we will get rid of all the problems that go with them. THAT IS A FACT!

DUHhaa - 7/3/2010 2:16 PM
3 Votes
Since when did illegal activity become ok ? isnt breaking the law just that mr attny general? and your scared that your worker might have to do what there paid to do ...work? nice to see your doing your job also...NOT!!!

enough - 7/3/2010 1:51 PM
3 Votes
WHAT PART OF ILLEGAL ACTIVITY DO SO MANY NOT UNDERSTAND?? WITH ALL THE ILLEGALS HERE, WHY ARE WE TURNING A BLIND EYE?? WHAT DOES THAT SAY TO LAW ABIDING CITIZENS?? WHAT ABOUT THOSE WHO HAVE SPENT THEIR ENTIRE LIVES LIVING BY OUR LAWS AND BEING CONTRIBUTING CITIZENS OF THE USA?? BUT OF COURSE, WE WOULDN'T WANT TO OFFEND THE ILLEGAL CRINIMALS, WOULD WE?? WHAT DO YOU SAY TO MY CHILDREN WHEN THEY SEE AAA THIS ILLEGAL ACTIVITY GOING ON?? OH SON, IT'S OK FOR THEM TO BREAK THE LAWS, BUT, IF YOU EVER DO, YOU WILL GO TO JAIL!!!

1jazzymama - 7/3/2010 10:44 AM
0 Votes
Utah, Arizona or whatever state wants to pass a new immigration law can, but how is it going to be enforced. Police are already streched thin are police officers really going to take the time to arrest an illegal immigrant who is working and otherwise obeying the law. They are only concerned with the illegals who commit serious crimes. We have immigration laws in place that are ineffective. This bill is no exception. It will be ineffective and prove frivolous. Is the state and federal government willing to spend money on training existing law enforcement officers in immigration and naturalization laws. Then they will have to higher alot more deportation officers and a host of others that it takes to actually prosecute an illegal offender. to deport the offenders. I am for reform to make it easier to enter the country legally and obtain a work permit.We should consider where the money will come from to enforce this law if it does take effect. As a side note to other comments, it is not only Mexicans who enter the U.S illegally; numerous Chinese enter the country illegally every year. To say it is only Mexicans is an incorrect statement.

Bob Rooney - 7/3/2010 9:32 AM
2 Votes
Illegals means MORE police, MORE sheriffs MORE border control, and more Crime. Push your state rep to make a change. Google this: numbersusa. Once you are registered, go to the "action buffet" to send FREE faxes now. Forward this to everyone you know.

goldnut - 7/3/2010 9:07 AM
3 Votes
There are somewhere between 11 an 40 millian illegalsin this country. What if we deport all the millions to Mexico and tell them to get rid of the drug dealers. I think 1 million mexicans should be enought to wipe out a few thousand drug dealers. Oh, they would rather hide up here under the protection of Shirleff and fly their flag instead of fixing their own country. Did you know Shirless is aksing the LDS church to stand up to the legislature about immigration laws? I guess our highest law enforcement official has never heard of seperation of church and state. Or may he is just incompetant. I bet on the imcompetant.

wiseguy - 7/2/2010 10:49 PM
3 Votes
Another though...this scare tactic / threat of crime rise is great for you!! With all of the illegals getting arrested of course the crime rate will rise. Hey this will give you job security more to do...because you certainly don't have enough to do now right?? Just more twisted political self interest to keep power...Send them back with a reminder of how tough is is here!! They have to work for FREE FOR A YEAR MINIMUM before returning home!! HOW ABOUT HAVING THEM BUILD MINIMUM HOUSING IN THE WEST DESERT FOR THEMSELVES AND OTHERS THAT NEED TO BE THERE. That way we get back some of what they have taken under false pretexts and the next batch won't come because there is no gain from being here...DUH...CRIME LEVELS WILL DROP IF LAWS ARE PROPERLY ENFORCED.
ABC 4 Poll
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.