Are weight limit rules putting youth football players at risk?


Story Comments Share
Updated: 9/09/2010 5:15 pm | Published: 9/06/2010 6:01 pm
Reported by: Noah Bond
Jordan Maroon Gremlins took the field against the Murray Spartans in Ute Conference youth football.
Ute Conference youth football

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah (ABC 4 News) - Parents say their kids aren't getting a fair shake when it comes to playing football. And when the league was unresponsive they turned to ABC 4 to take action.

The controversy has to do with weight limits.  If a kid weighs more than a certain amount in little league football the rules say the player is not allowed to carry the ball, but this year the rules have changed in one league and parents and coaches say it's putting the kids at risk.

Coach Percy Pearson says this year is going to be a bit tougher for his squad this year.

At the beginning of the season all the players had to weigh in. Any kid who weigh more than 100 pounds got and "X" taped on their helmet.  The "X" means they're forbidden from carrying the football.

The idea is to avoid a larger kid from hurting a small kid. Most kids missed by just a pound or two.  ABC 4 talked to several parents who say their children weighed in at barely over 100 pounds and they think their kids should have a second chance to weigh in and have the "X" removed.

According to the league's own by-laws, the kids should get that chance.  Rule 13.5 reads, "there may be a weigh in of "X'ed" players...to give them the opportunity to have the "X" removed."

This year the players are not being given that chance.  "Only 10 to 12 kids made weight.  So about six skilled players for about two teams and they said we have to learn with that," said Pearson.

Mom's like Tanira Goins are worried about safety for her son, "I feel like he deserves somewhat of a break especially with this being his first year."

Mike Wiley is the President of the UTE Football League.  He says the rule allowing kids to weigh in a second time changed more than a year ago.  He says the fact that it's still here in the rule book is a typo.  "It was a misprint.  You find a misprint in about everything you do...unfortunately it happened here.  It's an unfortunate situation and I personally feel bad about it," said Wiley.

If it really is all about the kids, is this rule change really fair to those who do want a chance to carry the ball?  "Is it fair?  No comment," said Wiley.

The league does say that after hearing all these concerns they will consider raising the weight limits for kids next year.

Story Comments Share
6 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of ABC4

kalanz - 8/2/2011 12:57 PM
I think the whole weight limit thing is UNFAIR! This is like asking a tall kid NOT to play Basketball because he is too tall. This is FOOTBALL people! If you are scared your kid is going to get hurt...maybe he should be playing something else! Try flag football or soccer. Football is a demanding sport and we shouldn't limit it's players potential, even at young ages!!! C'mon GET REAL!!!

GizaHead - 10/24/2010 9:54 AM
We have played for a few seasons now and things are hard to change. This is an old idea, but how about teams based on size? This would give every small kid a chance to PLAY and have FUN. There is plenty of time in the upper schools to get smashed. Also, it will help the bigger kids grow their skills for more years of competitive play. The whole making weight thing should be left to wrestling.

MattGephardt - 9/9/2010 5:20 PM
Reading2Much - My name is Matt. I wrote this story for Noah. It's not so much what I think as what parents think. But, yes, I would have to agree that having teams with very few "non-X-men" could put kids at risk. Even the big boys go into and come out of games. But, with so many X-men and so few boys who are allowed to carry, they could be forced to play more than is safe.

Teine - 9/7/2010 1:02 PM
I totaly agree with previous comments. The risk is coming from the parents who are basically starving their kids to make weight. My big guy has been an X since he started litte league and its not fair to him because he's never had the chance to run the ball but its no big deal hes happy playing as an X man and just cuz your little guy isnt an X doesnt mean he wont get hit by the big guys when he runs on the inside. If you're really scared of your kid playing football maybe you should sign him up in a different sport more suited for his size, maybe an individual sport like swimming. Swimming is awesome.

Reading2Much - 9/7/2010 12:05 PM
This is the most silly story ever. Channel 4 you really think the weight limit is putting kids at risk? So, limiting the weight of the kids who can carry the ball (so a 135 lb kid isn't running over a 60 lb kid) somehow increases risk? Add in the fact that by allowing a 2nd weigh in you are encouraging young kids ages 8-14 to lose significant weight through unsafe methods? This is just the griping of a coach in the program who wants a big kid to be able to carry the ball so his team can win and he can relive his own glories days vicariously. Whoever screens your stories needs to be replaced and find someone with a little commen sense.

sportsgirl - 9/6/2010 10:31 PM
If the kids who weigh in more than the weight limit are allowed to weigh in again, the kids that won't be getting a fair shake are the normal-weight kids who will be more at risk of getting injured. The thing I can't believe is that there are actually parents out there that will let their kids, as young as 8 years old, try to quickly lose weight so they will be under the "X" limit, which is definitly not healthy for children to be doing, and then as soon as they make the weight they go back to eating normally and become more than the "X" weight, which puts other kids at risk. If a child is over the limit, their parents should help them out on the off season by having them get some exercise and eat healthy to lose weight in a healthy manner so they can try to be less than the "X" weight for the next season. Some kids just aren't going to be able to be less than the "X" limit because they are naturally bigger and taller, but not overweight, than their peers of the same age. The fact is that most of the "X" kids are overweight. Also, the 100-pound limit stated in the story is not for all age groups. It starts out at 76 pounds and goes all the way up to 165 pounds, depending on the age. The rules are in place for a reason, to keep kids safe, and the parents should just deal with it.
ABC 4 Poll
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.