Brent Hunsaker's reporter notebook -- When is found ... not found?


Story Comments Share
Updated: 9/16/2011 5:14 pm | Published: 9/16/2011 1:55 pm
Reported by: Brent Hunsaker
Remains found during Susan Powell search (ABC 4 News)
Remains found during Susan Powell search (ABC 4 News)
Journalists aspire to be Wordsmiths.

We try to be careful in the use of language. We try to be accurate and use words accurately. We try.

So it is frustrating beyond words when others do not.

Stop! Time out! 

Before I go on, I want to make it clear that West Valley Police have a tough job. The Susan Cox Powell case is complicated. No witnesses to a crime (if there is one). No body (again, if there is one).


From the Chief on down, they should be given a standing ovation for continuing to work so hard to find out what happened to her.


They have not given up. That says a lot about their integrity and determination.


Okay, back to my complaint.

Don't say you've "found" something when you haven't.

If a cadaver dog sits down -- hits on a spot in the middle of the brush and dry grass at the foot of an extinct volcano, then say so! Explain what that means. Surely that won't give away any secrets or compromise the investigation.

But for Heaven's sake, don't say, "We've found human remains. We're confident they're human."

Found means you've seen it. You can hold it. Possess it.

The New World wasn't "found" by Columbus just because a few seagulls did a flyby of La Nina, La Pinta and Santa Maria. He saw it. He went ashore and walked on it. (Of course, he thought it was the East Indies ... but that's another matter.)

A dog or several dogs "indicating" on a spot of earth is not "found."

Digging in that spot and uncovering hair or bone or tissue, now that's "found."

Taking those remains back to a lab for analysis, that's "found."

A dog with an incredible sniffer ... not found.

West Valley police have not yet "found" human remains near Topaz Mountain.  Yet.

We can only pray that when something is found it will unravel the mystery of Susan's disappearance.
Story Comments Share
3 Comment(s)
Comments: Show | Hide

Here are the most recent story comments.View All

The views expressed here do not necessarily represent those of ABC4

Rhonda Morin - 9/16/2011 9:39 PM
0 Votes
I disagree with you now... I agreed with you the other day and freaked out but NOW I understand what they were saying. The dogs hit on something and what they hit on IS human. We will dig the next day. When they started digging, nothing. So they look like chumps BUT there is something there, 2 sets of dogs would not alert if it wasn't. My nephew has an allergy dog, one of 4 in the country that alerts on milk. it is amazing to watch and I have wanted a cadaver dog because of THIS case. I felt if dogs were used long ago she might have been found earlier. Whether Susan's body is in that spot or any human body is in that spot, it's hard to tell BUT I believe there WAS a body in that spot. The dogs will alert to that. It just dawned on me, Daddy Powell went away a few weeks ago when they went in the house and got all the computers and such. I am a theory person, perhaps Daddy Powell came and moved her body.... just thinking. May there be resolution soon.

Linda Oz - 9/16/2011 6:56 PM
0 Votes
Mr. Hunsaker, I see your point, however when 5 or 7 certified cadaver dogs, with proven track records, alert on a location, remains are most likely there. Just because remains can't be seen with the naked eye, does not mean they are not there. Even a drop of flood is human remains. I realize reporters have a tough job out there with no cell contact, but they need to report what they hear, not what they assume, i.e. everyone reporting on Wednesday that "bones have been found". Police never said that. Perhaps it could have been made more clear by police, but it is the reporters job to verify before publishing.

Larmo - 9/16/2011 2:26 PM
0 Votes
It seems to me the real story here is that WV Police have done a very poor job handling the press. I agree with you completely. From the whole, "Press conference in Ely at 10:00 AM" thing, to, "we've found human remains". They need to think BEFORE they talk.
ABC 4 Poll
Inergize Digital This site is hosted and managed by Inergize Digital.
Mobile advertising for this site is available on Local Ad Buy.